Jon WilcoxTuesday 01 June 2010, 2:48PM
Early last year we looked at the Canadian flagship mdBriefCase website.
Coincidentally, soon after that review I had an interesting chat
with the team from mdBriefCase Australia while at the 2009 Sydney
GPCE Conference.
While the Australian version is conceptually similar to its
parent site (as a free provider of primary care CME rather than
medical news), the Australian version is still a little different.
Established in January 2006, it uses only local Australasian
modules produced by specialist contributors (mostly from the
western side of the ditch). And, it would seem that perhaps the
repertoire of topics and management guidelines should better
reflect our similar trans-Tasman approaches to primary care
medicine than the North American site.
The website claims to have a base of 15,000 subscribers, mostly
presumably in Australia and New Zealand.
Fortuitously, mdBriefCase Australia did catch my eye again this
week with the promotion of a new module on the site titled
"Diagnosing and Managing Bipolar Depression in General Practice".
Coincidentally, my interest in the intriguing nature of the bipolar
disorders had been stimulated after an excellent presentation at
the same Sydney conference last year and also following the tragic
death of a friend by suicide some weeks before.
There now appears to be significant acknowledgement at a global
primary care level of the diagnostic constraints of the DSM-IV
which have perhaps substantially handicapped the accurate diagnosis
and the optimal and timely management of the various types of
bipolar depression for possibly decades. Indeed, some commentators
have noted that up to 40 per cent of patients with an intrusive
bipolar disorder are not diagnosed for at least 10 years and that
69 per cent of those patients eventually diagnosed with a bipolar
disorder had been previously misdiagnosed on an average of three to
four times before appropriate therapy was able to be
established.
So, with at least 40 in every 1000 of our patients having a likely
covert background of either BP I, BP II, cyclothymia or other forms
of bipolar disorder, and more mental health funding slowly flowing
into primary care here in New Zealand, there is now an evolving
opportunity for our primary care teams to better manage this
seriously neglected segment of the mental health community.
The module itself was excellent and, as with our own Goodfellow
Unit website, really exemplifies the importance of having locally
based CME articles. In this case, the detailed resource materials
were from the 2004 Australian and New Zealand Clinical Practice
Guidelines for the Treatment of Bipolar Disorder (sponsored in
part by our own ministry-directed health funding
organisations).
As with the Canadian parent site, it is also notable, however,
that there is a limited number of topics available for the CME
modules. It is accepted - and our Goodfellow Unit would surely
agree - that designing and preparing such modules for web-based
access is time-consuming and thus each module requires a sponsor.
While in New Zealand we have tended to move more away from industry
affiliated sponsorships for CME - with the possible exception of
ACC - to more of a hands-off involvement, this does not quite seem
to be the case in Australia and all modules appear to be sponsored
by a company with a major product in that field. The site does,
however, emphasise that it "adheres to a strict transparency policy
on physician-sponsor roles".
The other negative feature of mdBriefCase Australia is it seems to
be a little clandestine in its pedigree. There is no advertised
board oversight and all the specialist prepared articles appear to
be reviewed by a single one-man band, GP Damian Flanagan.
There are only 13 modules available at the moment and it might be
perceived as a little bit of a hotch-potch with topics such as
macular degeneration, malaria and NSAID-gastritis, plus all that
perpetual "same old stuff" viz acne, cardiovascular risk,
osteoporosis, hepatitis A and B, allergic rhinitis, asthma, HPV,
depression, COPD and psoriasis.
The modules are said to expire and be taken off the site every 12
months, perhaps having less to do with currency and more to do with
time-limited financial support. The modules are also undated which
is a little disconcerting, though one can get a reasonable idea of
currency with the dates of comments posted in the individual module
discussion groups.
It is well worth having a look at mdBriefCase Australia if only to
update ourselves on the bipolar disorders, and it would also be
worth having another look at the parent Canadian site at
mdBriefCase.com for comparison.
|
Wilcox
web reviews
Out of Five Stars
High quality
content
♦ ♦ ♦ ♦
Up to date
♦ ♦ ♦ ♦
Good presentation
♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦
Level of unfettered access
♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦
Useful patient information
♦ ♦
Interactive CME
♦ ♦ ♦ ♦ ♦
|